
Begging
So you have a dog that begs. It seems every time you go to enjoy a meal, or a tasty treat, your dog is right there. Staring into your soul. Waiting for the moment you drop a crumb. Hoping that you may look on them with pity and share the delicious smells. They sit and watch you take bite after bite. Maybe you are the type of person who gives them some food. Or perhaps you stare back and get irritated. It is possible that you are a little bit of both. Sometimes sharing and other times, keeping every last bite to yourself.
So let us ask some questions. What is begging? Why does it happen? When is it a problem? How do I make it stop?
Some of these questions you will need to ask and answer yourself. Never fear, I am going to break this down for you, barnie style.
What is Begging?
I am sure this is one question you can answer on your own. In this context we will say, begging is any action taken by your dog that, they believe, has a chance of getting you to do something.
Most commonly we see a dog that stares. Begging can happen for any reason. Needing to use the restroom, wanting pets, “please, just throw the ball!”. Your dog may want the food you are eating or maybe, they know it is close to time for their afternoon walk.
Begging can also come up in other ways. Pushing your hand with their nose, whining, barking, jumping and sometimes, nipping.
Why does it happen?
To answer this question we need to look at two things.
First the dog's natural needs and desires. Second, reinforcement history.
Your dog has many natural instincts, biological needs and personal desires. It is crucial that your dog has outlets for all of these categories. When there is a deficit in one of these categories your dog will try to fill the empty space themself. We solve a chewing problem by providing things to chew. If your dog is taken out on a regular schedule, there is no need to beg for a bathroom break. Begging to go to the bathroom is usually an acceptable form of begging. It is better than an accident in the house.
Some natural instincts, like the instinct to smell and eat, can work against us. A dog will be naturally curious about delicious smelling food that you are eating. They will naturally want to figure out how to get it from you. This is one type of begging a lot of humans dislike.
Now, let’s explore reinforcement history.
Everything your dog has tried has a reinforcement history.
Reinforcement happens whether you are actively giving your dog reinforcement or not. Dogs are pattern recognition machines! They are learning patterns every second of the day and they are good at it. Oftentimes they know our patterns better than we do. They are also excellent gamblers. If the pay out is high enough, a dog will continue to try, just in case it works, this time. Why reinforcement history matters when we talk about begging is simple. The dog's natural instinct gets them to start trying behaviors. Your dog says “Staring, ok that’s not working. Pacing? No again. Picking up the ball? YES I got the human to play with me!” In this example the dog wanted to play, threw out some behaviors until one worked. When the dog barks you look at them. When they put their paw on your leg, you pet them. In some ways begging can tell us what our dogs want. In a lot of ways it is an essential tool for communication.
When is it a problem?
This is a question you have to ask, and answer yourself.
Everyone has a different idea of what life with their dog looks like. I would say begging that is uninterruptible is a problem. When we cannot redirect or stop the begging it has a risk of escalating. Extinction bursts can be useful in getting to the other side of a behavior. However, if we give in during the extinction burst we can see behaviors escalate to shoving or biting due to increased frustration and inconsistent reinforcement history.
So ask yourself, when does begging bother me? Are their times when begging helps my relationship with my dog? What do I usually do when my dog begs?
Remember that begging is context based and can look different depending on what your dog is asking for.
How do I make it stop?
First, ask yourself what your dog needs or wants right now? Is it something you are able to provide?
If you are able to provide for your dog's needs at that moment, do it. If you are not, try to find an alternative. If you can’t play right now, can you give your dog a puzzle toy? If you are unsure of how to provide an alternative, or how to teach alternate behavior IE “go lay down” hiring a trainer would be a perfect next step.
For this portion I am going to use the example of begging for food. Most other examples are either acceptable forms of begging or should come with professional help I.E. Whining or barking to be let out of their kennel.
Begging for food is common and normal. It is also very annoying to a lot of pet owners. If you are a person that is unbothered by table begging, this is not for you. With puppies this can be easily handled by never reinforcing begging for food in the first place. The puppy can be put in their crate or play pen during meal times. Or if the puppy is potty trained and out of their crate stage, we would give them a high value chew and place them on their bed during human meal times. When the puppy comes over to see what you’re doing and what that smell is, send them immediately back to their bed. Never give your dog food from your plate or while you are at the table. Even doing this every once in a while will build an inconsistent reinforcement history. Because dogs are excellent gamblers, your once in a while treat, becomes their all the time stare.
When your dog starts to escalate beyond the staring phase, maybe they are barking, or nosing you, you need to start a management plan.
Baby gates are a great help. Crates, playpens, or “place” cues can also be used to manage the begging. By stopping access to the area where you eat, you set the dog up for success. It will also prevent the practice of the behaviors. Because when we practice, we get better. You can also set them up for success with something they can chew on while they wait for you to finish your meal. Cow hooves are great, a little smelly though. Frozen bones or a stuffed kong are also great options.
My personal cue is “go lay down”.
I am a person that is not so bothered by the staring. I start to get bothered when the dog starts getting really close to my space or vocalizing. I admit that I will share with my dogs sometimes. Because I have created an inconsistent reinforcement history it would be unfair to expect them to not beg. I let them know that, “I am not sharing this time” by sending them to their beds. This is what works in my house but we know that every dog and every house is different.
Tying all of it together
Begging is a natural and sometimes useful behavior.
It is the mechanism that teaches our dogs how to tell us when they want something.
Meeting all of your dogs' needs removes the need for most forms of begging.
Management is a key component to preventing and treating begging.
Offer an alternative behavior if you cannot meet the need at the moment.



Socialization
Let’s Talk About It
I’m sure you have heard about socialization in dogs. But what is it? Why is it important? How do I do this effectively? With all the information out there it’s hard to know if what we are doing is the correct move for our puppies.Never fear, I am going to break this down for you Barnie style.
When I was teaching group classes I would ask my students, “What does Socialization mean to you?” Most of the time I got the same answer. Meeting other dogs and people. It makes sense in human vocabulary to say socialization is the act of being social. Now, this is correct but is missing SO much more information. Socializing your dog, in simple terms, is getting them used to things they will encounter in the real world. In training terms I would say; Socialization is the act of habituating your dog to everyday stimuli. Sciencey jargon aside I plan to make this simpler for you. Let’s dive it.
WHEN
The “when” is so important. Growing puppies have a specified socialization period. During this time their brain is constantly taking in new information and noting if it is dangerous or not. It is not a large window ending at only 16 weeks of age. Once we pass this precious 4 month mark we are no longer socializing. We have flipped the switch into counter conditioning. Set a goal for when you bring puppy home to introduce them to one new thing everyday. Put on your sunglasses and toss some treats or play. Go for a walk with an umbrella. Meet different people, different ages, colors and maybe even that nice man in the wheelchair. Sit at the park and just watch. Get that pup used to the sights and sounds of living with humans. It’s a busy world out there.
HOW
It is very important to make sure the puppy isn’t becoming overwhelmed or building a fear of everyday items. If someone comes to greet your pup and they hide, or seem uncomfortable, we should not force this contact. Instead, politely decline pets and offer the stranger a treat they can TOSS to your puppy. Handing it to them is just a way to trick the puppy into touching someone they are wary of. Let the pup make the decision to say hi. This may seem counterintuitive but this will help build your pups confidence in themself, and their trust in you. When you notice puppy is scared of the can on the street, don’t scold them for barking or trying to get away. Instead reward them for bravery. Took a step towards the scary garbage, “Good dog”. Sniffed an object with ALL their weight shifted backwards, “Oh what a brave puppy! Here’s a treat.”
Allow them to sniff!
We are too caught up in rushing through a walk. Let me change your goal for you. Instead of your goal being a lap around the park your new goal is, enrich your dog's life. Every time you let them get a good sniff you are achieving this goal. The older they get the more boring those everyday smells will become. They are less likely to obsessively sniff as adults if they have already ruled out that the smell is, in fact, from a bird, and move on quickly. You are seeing your world with your eyes. Your dog is smelling the world with their nose. We can look at numbers and data, but there is no way to truly comprehend how sensitive the canine nose is to information. So let them sniff!
WHERE
Everywhere you go! Your puppy is constantly taking in new information. It is asstounding to see how fast young minds decide what is safe and what is not. If your pup is not fully vaccinated you can do exercises at home or put pup in a wagon to keep them off the ground. Always remember your treats and your poop bags. Taking some cleaning wipes is a good idea as well. Taking a trip to home depot? Plop that puppy in a cart! Headed to PetSmart? Drag that pup along for the ride.
SOUND
I do want to briefly touch on socialization to sound. I really enjoy having dog tv for my pups. This may seem a little silly to some. Hear me out though. Dog tv plays a variety of sounds. It has images of dogs doing different activities and has a multitude of different items on screen. Such an easy way to expose pup from home when you can’t get out. I also like to play sounds on youtube. Horns honking, cars, thunder storms and different barks. If we know our neighbors blow off fireworks at different times of the year, I might venture as far as to play explosion sounds. If your puppy is overwhelmed by any played sound effects, turn the volume down and try again. You can bump the volume up over time. Our goal is that they don’t care about the sound at all.
TOUCH
Humans are handsy things. We want to touch all the things! We have to make sure pups are used to being touched and handled. Touch a paw and couple it with a treat. Touch an ear and give a favorite toy. Never hold on for the rodeo. If the puppy wants to pull away, let them. Try at a lower intensity next time. Puppy pulled away from holding its tail, next time I’ll just touch it for a second. Build on these skills as you go. Your veterinarian and groomer will thank you.
The End is Here
This was a very brief overview of what we really mean when we say “Socialize your dog.” It is not just learning to be friendly. It is learning to cope with everyday life. To be calm around new things and to accept that the man in the sunglasses is not some other worldly being who has come to take away everything you love. That the wind in the trees is not a threatening display from an enormous creature. Most importantly, when done properly, it teaches your dog that you will control their environment so they don’t have to.
If you enjoyed this read and want more information, or help, socializing a new pup please contact Kelsey Caviezel with KC’s K9’s Positive Reinforcement Training
Find the Place Where Training Meets Freedom








